Showing posts with label Jharkhand Bids. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Jharkhand Bids. Show all posts

Friday, December 20, 2013

Jharkhand Rural Distribution Opportunity, Expert Opinions and IUKAN 2014 Updates - Dec, 2013 Newsletter

This is a newsletter for the month of Dec, 2013 sent to mailing list of pManifold sharing Power Distribution Franchisee industry opportunities and updates. 

Some of the recent updates from the Power Distribution Franchisee model are mentioned below. Hope, you find it useful.   

New Opportunities
  • Jharkhand State Electricity Board (JSEB) has floated tender for appointment of Rural Distribution Franchisee in its 8 areas under different sub-divisions. Last date of bid submission is 17th Dec, 2013. (More details can be seen at NIT, RFP, DFA)  
Expert Opinions
  • Views on Managed IT services for Distribution Franchisee by Mr. Ananth Chandramouli, Head - Energy and Utilities, Infosys (Read here)
Trends & Analytics
  • CARE Research recent report on Power Transmission and Distribution indicates Distribution Franchisee as a preferred model for PPP route in the sector (Read here)
Update on IUKAN Annual Conference 2014
  • In the last 2 weeks, me and my colleagues have spoken to industry leaders from over 200+ companies across power and water sectors. The response has been extremely overwhelming especially for the Best Practices Awards being launched with IUKAN. 
  • Online registration for the conference is now open. Early bird registration ends on 1st January, 2014. Use Discount code - IUKAN2014-EARLYBIRD to avail 20% discount.
  • See updated list of IUKAN Advisors here.
pManifold's Utility Practice can be viewed here, If you would like to know more about us, please contact at kunjan.bagdia@pmanifold.com.

Posted by: Kunjan Bagdia @ pManifold

Friday, November 22, 2013

PESU DF on-hold, Essel begins Muzaffarpur DF, IUKAN 2014 - Nov, 2013 Newsletter

This is a newsletter for the month of Nov, 2013 sent to mailing list of pManifold sharing Power Distribution Franchisee industry opportunities and updates.

Last month has been slow for Power Distribution Franchisee industry, as 2 opportunities (i.e. PESU Distribution Franchisee and Jaipur's Technical Feasibility Consultant) have seen little progress. Please see below more information about the updates. 

Existing Opportunities
  • PESU bid stands cancelled, as of now. (Read here) 
Roll Outs & Updates
  • Essel Utilities takes over power distribution in Muzaffarpur, Bihar from 1st Nov, 2013. (Read here)
  • Spanco Nagpur Discom Limited (SNDL) to launch SMS service for complaints lodging and bill updates for its consumers. (Read here)
  • Financial bid opening and evaluation for consultancy assistance to implement Distribution Franchisee in Jaipur Vidyut Vitaran Nigam Ltd (JVVNL) is still due. (Stay tuned for updates)
​Indian Utility Knowledge and Networking (IUKAN) 2014

IUKAN is back! Its Bigger...Its Better!!! (Block your dates)

The pManifold team brings to you the 2nd Annual Conference of India Utility Knowledge and Networking forum (13-February-2014 | Le Meridien, New Delhi) with focus on Power and Water Distribution Utilities. The theme for this edition is  'Complimenting Reforms Bottom-up through Improved Operationalization and Engaged Local Ecosystem', with separate focused tracks in Power Distribution (see Power Track Agenda) and Water & Waste Water (see Water Track Agenda).
 
For Best Practice Awards (Get in touch Now to Nominate yourself)

The Awards intend to recognize best practices employed at all business and operating levels of a water, waste water and power distribution utilities thereby driving improve service levels across the industry. If you want to be recognized as the leader in a particular area, then get in touch with us to discuss/nominate. 

pManifold's Utility Practice can be viewed here, If you would like to know more about us, please contact at kunjan.bagdia@pmanifold.com.

Posted by: Kunjan Bagdia @ pManifold

Tuesday, October 8, 2013

Jharkhand's DF on-hold, PESU bids again extended, MoP New Initiatives, IUKAN 2014 - Oct, 2013 Newsletter

This is a newsletter sent to mailing list of pManifold sharing Power Distribution Franchisee industry opportunities and updates.

Some of the recent updates in the Power Distribution Franchisee space are shared below. Hope, you will find it useful.

Existing Opportunities
Roll Outs & Updates
  • Bids for consultancy assistance to implement Distribution Franchisee in Jaipur Vidyut Vitaran Nigam Ltd (JVVNL) has been submitted by four companies (Crisil, PwC, IL&FS and Feedback). Financial bid opening is still due. (Read here)
  • Jharkhand's Ranchi and Jamshedpur Input based Distribution Franchisee is put 'On-hold', as State Power Minister is planning to conduct an audit to evaluate the feasibility of the model. (Read here)
New Initiatives
  • Ministry of Power (MoP) proposes to bring Management Responsibility for State owned DISCOMs through proposed new bill by state governments to ensure financial and operational turnaround and long term sustainability of electricity distribution. (Read here) 
  • MoP has recently released 'Smart Grid Vision and Roadmap for India' with an overarching policy objective of Access, Availability and Affordability of Power for All. (Read here)
  • MoP has set up a group that is working on ways to implement the plan which will require a separation of the distribution and the retail supply business, with separate licences for each. (Read here)
Share your vote
  • Should centre mandatorily extend R-APDRP funding to all Franchisee towns to enable better franchisee operationalization and also viability? (Vote here)
Indian Utility Knowledge and Networking (IUKAN) 2014
  • pManifold team is glad to bring 2nd Annual IUKAN 2014 Conference, on 12-13th Feb 2014 at New Delhi. IUKAN 2014 theme is 'Complementing Reforms Bottom-up: Through Improved Operationalization and Engaged Local Ecosystem. (See draft Conference Agenda)
  • One of the distinction of IUKAN 2014 is first of its kind Best Utility Awards to recognize operational best practices and innovations across multiple processes. 
  • On 1st day, we shall be hosting 2-4 parallel workshops, interested Service Providers can connect to us for more details.
pManifold's Utility Practice can be viewed here, If you would like to know more about us, please contact at kunjan.bagdia@pmanifold.com.

Posted by: Kunjan Bagdia @ pManifold


Friday, September 6, 2013

Jaipur Franchisee opportunity, Updates from PESU & Dhanbad, Expert Interviews, pManifold's New Report Launch - Sep, 2013 Newsletter

This is a newsletter sent to mailing list of pManifold sharing Power Distribution Franchisee industry opportunities and updates.

Last month, the Power Distribution industry saw various developments across different states. Some of these are mentioned below. We hope you will find them useful.  

New Opportunities
  • Jaipur Vidyut Vitaran Nigam Ltd (JVVNL) has floated a tender for Consultancy assistance to implement Distribution Franchisee in its 3 Discoms namely Jaipur, Ajmer and Jodhpur. 3 discoms have 18 areas for the study. Last date of bid submission is 26th September, 2013. (Read here)
  • Bihar Discom has floated tenders for selection of implementing agency for 'Strengthening, Improvement and Augmentation of Distribution System Capacity" under Backward Region Grant Fund (BRGF) scheme on Turnkey basis. (Read here)

Monday, August 5, 2013

Franchisee updates from Jharkhand & PESU, Expert Interviews & more - Aug, 2013 Newsletter

This is a newsletter sent to mailing list of pManifold sharing Power Distribution Franchisee industry opportunities and updates.

Some of the recent updates about the industry are mentioned below:

New Opportunities
  • Jharkhand State Electricity Board (JSEB) has floated new RFP documents for appointment of 'Rural Distribution Franchisee' on the basis of 'Collection Based Model' in its 15 sub-divisions comprising of following Area Board: Ranchi, Jamshedpur, Hazaribag. 4 sub-divisions out of 15 are same as per the earlier released tender document in Feb, 2013. The key activities for the participating bidder includes meter reading, billing, collection, minor operation and maintenance of the LT/HT network, attending fuse calls, etc. Last date of bid submission is 27th August, 2013. (Request For Proposal, Distribution Franchisee Agreement and Notice Inviting Tender can be read here in details)
  • South Bihar Power Distribution Company Ltd (SBPDCL) has re-initiated tenders through e-procurement mode only for selection of bidders for PESU area. Last date for request of bid document has been extended till 10th Aug, 2013 and for bid submission is 12th Aug, 2013. ('Pre-bid conference replies, RFP and Corrigendum'can be downloaded here)       

Wednesday, September 5, 2012

Delayed Bids opening: Perceived risks from 'few & new' players

Both Mumbra-Shil-Kalwa and Jharkhand Distribution Franchisee (DF) bids are pending for bid opening for more than a month. SAIL has only recently open the Bhilai bid, while other 3 areas are still pending. There seems no check on the utilities to monitor governance on the bid process, and be responsible to its bidders. One likely inferred reason for this delayed response from DISCOM is its perceived risk of non-performance from following:

  • Few number of bids received 
    • Mumbra: 3 out of 11 RFP purchasing companies
    • Jharkhand: 2 out of 6 only qualified companies
  • Most new entrants, with no prior experience in the Distribution business
    • Mumbra: Konark, Saicare InfoSystem (SIS) and Supreme Infra
    • Jharkhand: JV of Essel & Enzen and CESC

There are increasing risks of Mumbra bid getting scrapped, looking at continuing delays of bid opening date, and previous legacy of bid scrapping with 5 bidders that time. Similar is the case with Jharkhand, with 2 bids received each for Ranchi and Jamshedpur, and only one for Dhanbad. It is understood, that the overall market confidence on DF model is low at the moment, mainly because of reported contractual non-performance at Nagpur and Aurangabad DFs. Also there has been no recent success story on DF model post Torrent at Bhiwandi. These apprehensions of high risk of another failure with a new player is what is likely leading the utility to consider bid scrapping.

While above utility apprehensions might have some grounds, the opposite of it i.e. 'an established & experienced player will do good' has also examples, that were found untrue. For example:

  • same Torrent, is struggling to stabilise the Agra model
  • Reliance continue to struggle with Orissa, and has itself invited different versions of DF models with limited success
So it is not the limited experience of new players, that is causing current slow down in DF, but its the Model characteristics & its resulting forced dynamics from lack of proper planning, and non-involvement of relevant stakeholders during the design phase. The non-attractiveness of the DF model in its existing form to bankers is not only SPANCO's and GTL's problem, but it's a high risk to all other bidders as well. 

Thursday, June 28, 2012

Price bid curves and analytics from Jharkhand Distribution Franchisee projects

Our recent blog 'Key comparison of revised RFPs for Jharkhand Distribution Franchisees' covered the baseline comparison between old and revised RFPs for 3 forthcoming Power Distribution Franchisees in Jharkhand - Ranchi, Dhanbad and Jamshedpur.

JSEB has given minimum benchmark input price curve for all the regions, mandating bidders to bid higher than given price curve for all 15 years. The bidders in pre-bid meeting has earlier requested to have no benchmarks, to allow them innovating on financial structuring. (See our blog Jharkhand Distribution Franchisee first pre-bid meeting) 


See below table with useful bid analytics
Jharkhand Min. Benchmark Input prices for Power procurement by DF (Source: pManifold)
Some top level observations:

  1. Steep growth rate of around 10% in initial first 2 years, with max. in first year; followed by receding growth rate to 2% by 5 years; almost stable and slow receding of around 1% until 10 years, and then another stagnant increase of less than 0.5% and below until 15 years. 
  2. Ranchi has lowest start point around Rs. 2/kWh, with Jamshedpur highest at Rs. 2.5/kWh
  3. Ranchi again has lowest end point around Rs. 2.75/kWh, with Dhanbad highest at around Rs. 3.2/kWh. Amongst 3 DF regions, Dhanbad ranks lowest in geographical area, highest in consumer density and highest in AT&C losses. This probably be the reason for its highest end point pricing, because otherwise it ranks lowest in most other metrics of pManifold's DF attractiveness matrix.
  4. The ratio of max. to min. rates for each curve is higher than 0.7. 
    • The highest ratio is for Jamshedpur, resulting into lowest delta of Rs. 0.540 between the max and min rates of price curve. 
    • The lowest ratio is for Dhanbad, resulting into highest delta of Rs. 0.938 between the max and min rates of price 
  5. The Levelised Input Price (LIP) calculated at discount rate of 11% is highest for Dhanbad at Rs. 2.876/kWh, followed by Jamshedpur, with lowest for Ranchi at Rs. 2.487/kWh. (Difference of around 40 paise).
  6. Average Billing Rate (ABR) of Ranchi is lowest at Rs. 3.050/kWh, revealing greater improvement opportunity for that DF. Dhanbad has highest ABR of Rs. 3.540/kWh, which is sort of contrasting with its highest AT&C losses, lowest revenue billing & collections, and also lower collection efficiencies (see Jhanrkhand's DF attractiveness Matrix for details)
  7. Ratio of ABR to LIP is highest 1.231 for Dhanbad, 1.226 for Ranchi and lowest 1.176 for Jamshedpur. (This ratio is static indication of profit margin for bidders, with close to 1.00 value is indication of lower margins and higher risks for DF operator)

pManifold's DF bid advisory services further augment our client's bidding strategy through consolidation of on-site (network and customer) intelligence and other secondary research on electricity value chain for the region and its customer's demographics (socio, economic, political, cultural). Also our Discom Advisory services provides support in preparation of baseline data for new coming DF regions, and integrated financial modeling of Distribution Licensee and Distribution Franchisee to study various trade-offs to design robust DF model and contract for true win-win of Discom and DF. 


Post by: Rahul Bagdia @ pManifold

Key comparison of revised RFPs for Jharkhand Distribution Franchisees

Recently (20th June 2012), Jharkhand has revised its Distribution Franchisee (DF) RFPs for 3 locations namely Ranchi, Dhanbad and Jamshedpur. See our previous blogs on Jharkhand:
DF Attractiveness Matrix, benchmarking old and revised RFPs is shown in the diagram below. Some major changes in revised RFPs (dated 20th June) compared to old are as follows:
Jharkhand DF Attractiveness Matrix - Revised vs. Old RFPs (Source: pManifold)
  1. The base year for the RFP baseline continues to be 2010-11. This is most surprising part of this bidding, with bidders to take a call on future with lagging past baseline information.
  2. The current DF scope has been extended to entire District level for all 3 areas. Geographical area of all 3 regions - Ranchi, Dhanbad and Jamshedpur, has increased multiple times by approx. 17, 5 and 27 times respectively. This is huge increase, with not much corresponding change in no. of customers and assets variations  (see 2nd and 3rd figure here), creating questions on authenticity of the RFP baseline. 
  3. Number of Divisions has increased in Dhanbad from 3 to 4, while remaining the same for other 2 regions. Again increase in Dhanbad divisions, is not correspondingly matching with increase in assets in revised RFP (see 2nd figure here), suggesting inconsistency. 

Tuesday, June 19, 2012

Relative DF Attractiveness Matrix for Jharkhand and Mumbra RFPs

Recently, new opportunities have emerged in Jharkhand and Maharashtra in Power Distribution Franchisee. See our earlier blogs on Mumbra (Maharashtra) and Jharkhand:
pManifold's DF Attractiveness Matrix on RFP data provides a quick study on new areas in Jharkhand & Maharashtra and its comparison with old one's like Nagpur, Jalgaon, Aurangabad, MP's 3 regions, etc. A coloring scheme is used for better visualization for favorable Distribution Franchisee parameters across each attributes.



Saturday, May 26, 2012

Jharkhand Distribution Franchisee first pre-bid meeting


The first pre-bid meeting for Jharkhand Power Distribution Franchisee was conducted on 21st May, 2012 at Ranchi. It was attended by 10+ companies senior representatives; JSEB team - Chairman, Member Finance, Member T&D, Chief Engineer Commercial & Revenue; and Transaction advisor JInfra (50:50 JV of IL&FS and Jharkhand Govt.) team. 

The companies that participated were Tata Power, Reliance, NDPL, CESC, JUSCO, IPCL, Essar Power, Spanco, Essel Power and PTC. With existing strict Technical Qualification, likely 4-5 companies only can qualify for bidding, and this was well debated in the meeting, and next RFP revision is looked upon anxiously.

Mr. S.N. Verma, Chairman JSEB made the opening remark welcoming good participation and expressing his confidence on Distribution Franchisee (DF) model to aid Distribution reforms and bring AT&C losses from current high approx. 46% to atleast 20% level. He justified selection of Ranchi, Jamshedpur and Dhanbad urban circles for DF model first pilot at Jharkhand, based upon their high industrialisation, significant domestic load, high AT&C losses, no rural areas and good recovery potential. He added that post successful roll out of these 3 DFs, JSEB would want to further scale-up the model with learnings in other cities. (See pManifold earlier blog with DF attractiveness matrix for 3 Jharkhand regions and comparing them with earlier DF areas - Jharkhand releases RFPs: Quick comparative analysis with different states RFPs)

Some key points that were discussed in the pre-bid meeting were as follows:

1. Baseline data consistency: Bidders brought various inconsistencies in the RFP baseline data, including anomalies, mistake in calculations and typos. These deals with bid sensitive parameters like AT&C losses, various efficiencies, average tariff (or ABR) etc. JSEB was humble to accept that they have issues with consolidating baseline data, specially in light of some mishaps with their billing agency at Ranchi and Jamshedpur. 

2. Missing information in baseline: Different bidders brought different missing information; they seek in the baseline data. Some important ones were – base year R15 data; Revenue and cost breakup across all customer segments; Electricity duty breakup in collection figures, subsidy breakup etc. Few bidders requested that at the minimum JSEB should share audited base year data for Input energy and collection figures.

3. Base year fixation: The current RFP has 2010-11 as its base year; with clause that while signing DFA, if new data is available, then base year could be changed. This was completely unacceptable to most bidders. They demanded that Base year and associated ABR should be freezed now and cannot be changed. Few of them believed that even if base year ABR is wrong (low or high), they can accommodate in their corresponding bid value. (The ownership risk across life cycle for both Licensee and Franchisee from this one important parameter, base year ABR’s uncertainty, seems to be missing in the stakeholders) 

Monday, May 14, 2012

Key Observations: Jharkhand RFPs of Ranchi, Dhanbad and Jamshedpur

Jharkhand released RFPs for 3 towns Ranchi, Dhanbad and Jamshedpur. Our earlier blog covered 'Brief comparative analysis of Jharkhand RFPs with different state RFPs'.    

Few key parameters of the Jharkhand RFPs are mentioned below:
  • Tenure for Input based Distribution Franchisee is 15 years for all the 3 towns.
  • Around 80% or more of the customers are 'Registered Customers' across all the 3 towns. 'Dhanbad' has highest 'Ineffective Customers', which is close to 20%. 
  • Operating areas ranging from 150 to 450 Sq.Km, with Jamshedpur as the smallest area.    
  • High AT&C losses for all 3 towns, with Jamshedpur having highest at 54%.
  • Distribution Franchisee shall make a minimum capital expenditure equivalent to 50% of Total Revenue Billed for a Base Year (for all 3 cities), in such a way that at-least 10% of the investment plan is spent every year for first 5 years of contract period.
  • Average Tariff/Billing Rate is lowest for Ranchi (Rs./kWh 3.18), followed by Jamshedpur (Rs./kWh 3.26) and Dhanbad (Rs./kWh 3.33).
  • The bidder has to achieve a level of 12% AT&C losses at the end of 7 years from the effective date, with year on year target loss reduction for each city.
  • Base or Benchmark Input Rate will be provided by the JSEB for each year during the pre-bid conference.
  • Collection Efficiency is highest in Dhanbad (95%), followed by Jamshedpur (94%) and Ranchi (89%). 
  • In case of shortage of 'Supply of Energy' by Jharkhand State Electricity Board (JSEB), the Distribution Franchisee may procure the power from other sources for expected shortfall, subject to concurrence of JSEB and its regulatory body.
  • For arrears realized by the DF from Permanently Disconnected (PD) customers in the first 3 years, an incentive of 20% shall be payable to DF net of taxes and duties. From 3rd to 6th years, an incentive of 15% and from 6th year onwards, an incentive of 10% shall be payable to DF. Arrears realized for the same period from Live customers will include an incentive of 15%, 10% and 5% respectively.
Indicative planned investment under R-APDRP Programme (Part A and Part B) undertaken by JSEB will be provided during pre-bid conference.

Please use below comment box to add more observations and information. 

Posted by: Kunjan Bagdia @ pManifold

Wednesday, May 2, 2012

Jharkhand releases RFPs: Quick comparative analysis with different states RFPs

Madhya Pradesh bidding saw Smart Wireless Ltd taking over as Distribution Franchisee operator for all the three locations i.e. Gwalior, Sagar & Ujjain. They have been awarded LOI and have also accepted the same for all 3 regions. They intend to start the 3 months joint operations with DISCOM by second week of May, and takeover completely before 15th August.         

Recently, Jharkhand released RFPs for 3 cities namely Ranchi, Dhanbad and Jamshedpur. The below image provides a quick study on new Jharkhand RFPs and its comparison with old one's (Nagpur, Gwalior). It depicts the brief comparison of some critical Attributes, which includes Factors like Electrical Network and Health, Consumption Patterns, Geography, etc. A coloring scheme is used for better visualization for favorable Distribution Franchisee parameters across each attributes.


MP bids took approximately 9 months from initial release of RFP in June,2011 till awarding of LOI of all the three locations in April,2012, with total 3 revisions in RFP in between. 

We hope that Jharkhand Government decision makers draws inputs from MP bids and expedites the awarding of locations by engaging all stakeholders.             

pManifold continues support Knowledge building in Power Distribution Franchisee model in India and help realise its potential. 

In continuous effort to scale Power Distribution Franchisee business model, pManifold has launched a 'Input Based Power Distribution Franchisee Market in India 2012Q1'. The report will provide detailed market, operational and financial insights into running a Power Distribution Franchisee. It will also include detailed previous bid analytics, including most recent from MP, future DF opportunities and trends. For more details and to download Executive Summary of our report, please see here. You can place your order with us at kunjan.bagdia@pmanifold.com.      

Posted by Kunjan Bagdia @ pManifold