Showing posts with label utilities. Show all posts
Showing posts with label utilities. Show all posts

Tuesday, March 18, 2014

Peeking into the challenges in managing waste water in the tier-2/3 cities in India

In the recently organized 2nd Annual India Utility Knowledge and Networking Conference, experts discussed the Business and Technology Innovations that are the need of the hour for scaling up the Waste Water Management in the tier-2/3 cities in India.

While access to safe drinking water is one challenge that remains to be solved, a corollary and equally significant and impacting health hazard is rising from accumulating municipal & industrial waste water and its untreated disposal. The major issues impacting waste water management are -

  • Cost effective Waste Water Treatment Technology; 
  • By-products use and market development; 
  • Economics and price adoption for Industrial use of treated waste water vs. fresh water; 
  • Public Private Partnerships structuring with clear roles and responsibilities, etc. 

In most ULBs, the reforms are yet to come in. There is still no answer for what to do with recycled water post primary treatment. Often such water is released in nearby water bodies as dissolved impurities in this water can be treated only through RO technology, which is expensive. 

Consider a typical Indian tier 2/3 city with population of 100,000 and about 120-135l water/person/day.  On an average, 80% of the supplied water returns as sewage. At this rate, the city would generate 10mld of sewage per day. 

Experts suggested that installing a 10mld capacity plant with the best in country technology would cost around Rs. 100-130 million i.e. Rs.1300/person investment required. Assuming a 10yrs life of one such plant, the costs come to Rs.130/person/year. This cost plus cost to collect water, suction pump etc put together, recycled water is available at Rs.40/person/month which is about Rs.1.35/person/day. 

If the Government of India considers a country wide investment in waste water treatment, the amount to be raised by government it amounts to (Rs.1.35 x total population of India) per day, which is a huge.


Commercialization of waste water can turn out to be a very useful step in encouraging more industries involved towards treating the waste water. Out 8% of total water supplied to industry, 70% goes to power plants. For Municipal corporations, OpEx still remains an issue since the CapEx is taken care by schemes like JnNURM. Of the total OpEx, 70-80% is the power cost. Without power, it is simply garbage in- garbage out. If power cost is taken care by methods like Group Captive Power Plants (GCPP), the Sewage Treatment Plants could become financially sustainable.

In one such initiative to commercialize and reuse the waste water, Maharashtra State Power Generation Company Limited (Mahagenco) and Nagpur Municipal Corporation (NMC), are jointly installing a 130mld Waste Water Treatment Plant in Nagpur. The NMC will allocate land and subsidy under the JnNURM program and Mahagenco will pay balance amount for project and bear opex. The recycled water would be supplied to Koradi Thermal Plant.

According to Central Pollution Control Board, in tier 2 and 3, only about 20% of total waste water is being treated. Less than 20% WWTPs are being utilized at their 100% capacity i.e.only 5-10% capacity is utilized to treat water. 

This calls for more time being spent on understanding the engineering and technology so as to make the waste water treatment business in India more viable.

====================================================================================
This panel had participation from Jal Board, State Government,. Technology Providers and Project Developers who shared their experiences, and brainstormed to build consensus on shaping an effective and integrated PPP models in Municipal Waste Water Management.

Also read: 

http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/nagpur/Mahagenco-to-give-Rs-15cr-to-NMC-for-waste-water-project/articleshow/3446853.cms

http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/nagpur/660MW-Koradi-unit-countrys-biggest-to-run-on-sewage-water/articleshow/24728967.cms

Tuesday, June 18, 2013

Top 15 - Field analysis of Customer Indexing for a Utility Company

GIS based consumer indexing is one of the effective tool to improve the complex network of consumers for the utility company. The complexity of network and minimal baseline data available, the utility needs to take substantial efforts on field to create a strong database of the consumer.

While working with a major water utility in India, some of our observations are listed below. These observations could help in creating a strong database of consumer.

Problems & Resulting Issues:

A) Systemic Problems (arising due to problem in process/system)

  • Background and purpose not clearly defined which is essential for correct inputs and improve the quality of data. 
  • Lack of strong processes and system base implementation for customer indexing
  • Recruitment of low quality people for on-field surveys which leads to lack of presentations skills, confidence, convincing capabilities, etc.
  • No processes for submission of on-field data which results in faulty batching of data and missing of survey forms
  • No regular updates of data (Monthly or Quarterly)
  • Lack of effort estimation and resource allocation which results in exceeding deadlines and duplication of efforts

B) Data Collection Problem (Due to Presentation / Understanding / Customer Support)

  • Wrong plot markings of property polygons in GIS base maps
  • Incomplete information filled by surveyor to achieve the daily target
  • Missed out consumers and properties by surveyors
  • No validation of Consumer Indexing process compliance by surveyors who are doing mistakes on field
  • No continuous tracking of surveyor records and inputs
  • Management of surveyors becomes difficult due to high attrition rate on-field
  • Difficulty in categorizing registered, unregistered and no-connection Consumers 
  • Lower level supervisors tackling the issues arising out of political influence may create unwanted barriers

Recommendations:

- Create a strong stakeholder (internal & external) agreement on what is required output of the consumer indexing survey
- One of the most effective ways to ensure high quality of data collected is to emphasize more on re-validation of the data by a field team
- Preliminary survey by taking GIS base map also helps to minimize GIS related issues on-field.
- On-field continuous training and quality monitoring of surveyors which will help minimise mistakes at ground level
- Appropriate costing and effort estimation is required for timely delivery of data
- Frequent updates of data is important which will help resolve to bring consistency in data

Prologue:

A systematic execution of customer indexing creates a whole new intelligence about the local variables. At the same time it can suggest strategic interventions which could be used for creating a positive cash flow for the utility.

Thursday, February 28, 2013

IUKAN Session 2 Proceedings: Understanding the utility customers - helping the utilities in better roll out of operationalize

With more and more utilities struggling to engage rightly with their customers, IUKAN 2013 was torch bearer in highlighting the best practices in providing insights into the whole customer engagement process. Some of the top leaders in the utility segment presented their views on how the customers form one of the most important, yet not recognized, pillars for the success of the utility operations.

The driving philosophy behind the session was to discuss the key challenges are utilities are facing in engaging with the customers. The session also talked of the vision for the utilities to have for its customer-engagement initiatives, in light of the fast changing nature of the utility customer.

Wednesday, January 30, 2013

Strategic Communications - A tool towards better customer engagement and loss reduction

The high risks in the complex, unpredictable and highly political process of water sector reforms are unavoidable given the "essential goods" perception of water. However, what the utility operators need to understand is that investing time and money in "strategic communications" early in the engagement of water reforms and that it leads to a much smoother operations and success of the project. A World Bank report (2006) suggests that an understanding of public perceptions leads to better adoption of strategic communications help in improving the efficiency of the public utility.

The key challenges arising due to lack of strategic communications can be listed as:

  1. Social conflict due to lack of information or misinformation or a communications vacuum that creates uncertainty
  2. Power struggles leading to project delays 
  3. Consumer Opposition due to (justified or unjustified) fears about tariff, service levels and affordability
  4. Customer dissatisfaction when hyped expectations are not met, or are not right sized at appropriate time
The idea behind this post is to try and identify areas where communication tools can support reform 
process and mitigate risks. 


The three principles which can be applied to use communications as a strategic tool towards better utility management are discussed here:

  1. Principle #1: Know-Your-Customer: Instead of making assumptions about what the customers want or how they would react, it is advisable to undertake a Communication-Based-Assessment (CBA) to gauge the support for utility reforms within the stakeholders. (See pManifold's unique COPS Case Study). The CBA uses a mixture of conventional and unconventional data collection methodologies (including socio-economic parameters, Willingness-To-Pay, opinion polls, etc.) and establish baselines for stakeholders' perceptions, interests and priorities.
  2. Principle #2: Creating Awareness about the Need for Utility Reform: Once the CBA has captured the perspectives of customers and stakeholders, the Utility Management may determine what about the reforms need to be communicated, through which messenger to communicate the same and how to garner political support with other political groups and agencies. The Utility Operator should:
    • create awareness regarding the "state of the utility" in terms of challenges and opportunities for reforms and what it means to the customers
    • communicate the effects/challenges that lie ahead, if reforms are not implemented. At the same time, if not communicated correctly, the Utility might risk being looked upon as non-transparent
    • make the stakeholders understand their rights and responsibilities in the reforms process
    • Principle #3: Building Support and System for Change: Once the reforms are enacted, the communications does not stop there. The Utility should continuously use communications as a tool to build a culture of transparency and openness
    The Utility, to leverage the strength of strategic communications as a tool, should make use of the following best practices:
    1. The communications strategy should integrally be linked with the organizational strategy & goals and be in line with the utility operations
    2. The Operator should take sufficient effort to make the information available and accessible to all the stakeholders. Establishing web portal and maintaining it constantly is critical to promote transparency.
    3. Correctly identify the most trusted messengers or champions through early use of CBA
    4. The Utility Operator should right size the expectations of customers as well as other stakeholders in order to mitigate the non-financial risks. Only when the beneficiaries believe that the project has met the set expectations, the Utility Operator can claim that the project has realized its full value
    5. More often that not, in our typical environment, project delays occur. And when they do occur, the Utility Operator should be taking care to communicate the reasons behind the delay. This creates an environment of openness and credibility.
    6. Whatever positive results are achieved by the Operator, the results should be communicated to the customers and other beneficiaries
    7. Empowering the media is one of the best methods to spread word about the good work the Utility is carrying out. The media also serves as a tool to educate the consumers.
    8. Collaborate with local governmental and non-governmental agencies to drive the Information-Communications-Education (ICE) campaigns to build a positive image for itself
    9. Utility should invest in creating and maintaining an in-house professional communications capacity to avoid the inefficiencies in the governmental / state agencies' communications program

    =========================================================================
    *Source: Communication for Water Sector Reform: Obstacles and Opportunities, (2012), The World Bank
    =========================================================================

    Wednesday, January 16, 2013

    Efficient Billing and Collection - Key to reducing NRW

    While exploring the various methodologies used by the water utilities to reduce Non-Revenue-Water (NRW), one of the better avenues available is achieving higher efficiency in the billing and collection processes. This blog explains the ideology behind the principle of higher billing and collection efficiency for reduced NRW.

    Now, the main components of losses in the whole water distribution system and the details of the commercial losses are explained in the figure.

    Categorization of losses

    Billing and Collection efficiency are the customer facing processes of the utilities and are quite independent from the other internal processes. Whatever consumer meter data is read and recorded, is used for billing. Further to that, recoveries from the consumers who are billed, is to be made. And hence, we are talking of Billing & Metering efficiency as a combined package, and area of focus.

    Improvements on these parameters are measurable as well as traceable to a bit higher degree than most others. Above all, these are processes which an utility can outsource to a vendor managed process. Optimum service delivery agreements and appropriate process control, guided using a Balanced Scorecard, can be designed and implemented, and therefore, do not burn a hole in the pocket of the operator to set up.

    Recommended readings:





    Sunday, October 14, 2012

    Case Study: Willingness To Pay for Water

    There has been an uncertainty around the success of the PPP models in the Indian Utility Market. While some of the fears are well placed, I think that one of the best ways to counter the apprehensions over the revenue projections of the operators, is the Willingness-to-Pay (WTP) analysis of the consumers in question.

    The WTP analysis provides a localized and a  stratified consumer response across the socio-economic categories, if well planned and executed. The figure below shows a typical boxplot drawn for a consumer analysis done for one of our clients.
    Box-Plot for a typical WTP Study

    The client - a private PPP Water Utility operator - had taken over the water supply project of a town with approx 2 lacs consumers. The operator had approached a leading institution for financing the over INR 1000 Cr.

    The institutional investor had his apprehensions about the revenue projections and had approached us to do the top-line validation through a WTP Survey and Analysis.

    The existing water supply condition of the city was very poor and residents were facing utmost difficulties in meeting their requirements through the ULB supplied water.

    We designed the WTP Study using the Contingent Valuation Methodology (CVM) and developed the  framework to execute the study. Key findings, which can be generally seen across other Water consumers, are shown in the adjoining figure.
    Key Findings of the WTP Study

    The findings helped the operator impress the necessity of the improved quality of water supply and prove that the people, if provided with better services, are willing to bear the cost for the service improvement as well.

    The WTP Study did manage to help the operator get to the financial closure.

    As we discussed the findings and success story of the WTP Study, we are now engaging with clients not just from the Utility Operators, but even from other service sector enterprises who want to validate their top-line projections before launching new or improved services.