Showing posts with label Smart Distribution. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Smart Distribution. Show all posts

Saturday, February 8, 2014

Discover Opportunities in Power & Water Distribution - Join IUKAN 2014, 13th Feb, New Delhi

IUKAN 2014 is focused on improving Utility Services in Urban Areas and covers power, water, waste etc. It is a very interesting platform that is build to get various stakeholders such as Policy Makers, Regulators, Operators, Service Providers, Consumers, Technology Players together and facilitate 'Rapid Scale Up’, 'Service Effectiveness’ and 'Financial Flows' to this important sector. 

IUKAN 2014, the 3rd such Event is to be held at Hotel Le Meridian, New Delhi on 13th February. It will have two parallel tracks, one on Power Distribution and other on Water Distribution including Waste Water, with focus upon improving their performance through faster reforms and PPP uptake. Its theme is 'Complimenting Reforms Bottom-up through Improved Operationalization and Engaged Local Ecosystem’. 


The Conference will see 12 panels, 50+ Speakers, 20+ Partners, 70+ Best Practice Award Nominees and total 300+ delegate participation. The Conference will provide an excellent networking platform for fellow industry professionals.

Thursday, August 29, 2013

Bottom-up innovation: From Micro Grid in Indian villages to Smart Grid for urban Discoms

Yashraj Khaitan, Co-founder
and CEO, Grampower
Bringing electricity to rural areas that never may see the grid is a great boon to both people's quality of life and the region's economy. Smart Grid Technology or Renewable Microgrid is the topic of this discussion to improve operational and business efficiency of Indian Power Utilities.
Grampower, a energy technology company is working on addressing the electrification challenges in India. 

pManifold recently spoke to Mr. Yashraj Khaitan, Co-founder and CEO of Grampower. The company sets up energy efficient Smart Microgrids in remote areas to provide on-demand, reliable electricity to telecom towers and rural households with an affordable prepaid purchase model. He has been instrumental in raising over USD1.7 million for the company, and leads product and business development and partnership building to scale the company's operations.The below shared are the author's personal views and not to be associated with any of his company's and other associations.

Thursday, February 28, 2013

IUKAN Session 2 Proceedings: Understanding the utility customers - helping the utilities in better roll out of operationalize

With more and more utilities struggling to engage rightly with their customers, IUKAN 2013 was torch bearer in highlighting the best practices in providing insights into the whole customer engagement process. Some of the top leaders in the utility segment presented their views on how the customers form one of the most important, yet not recognized, pillars for the success of the utility operations.

The driving philosophy behind the session was to discuss the key challenges are utilities are facing in engaging with the customers. The session also talked of the vision for the utilities to have for its customer-engagement initiatives, in light of the fast changing nature of the utility customer.

Friday, December 9, 2011

Impact assessment for Open Access to 1MW+ customers

DIRECTIVE:

The Ministry of Power Govt. of India issued a directives for implementation in the all States of India, after seeking consultation with Ministry of Law and Justice and said that,
“Section 42(ii) read with the first and fifth proviso is a self-contained code with regard to consumers who required the supply of electricity of 1 MW and above and accordingly the State Electricity Regulatory Commissions cannot continue to regulate the tariff for supply of electricity to any consumer of 1 MW and above”.

“The provisions of section 42 need to be analyzed in relation to the duties of the distribution licensees and open access.  While sub-section (2) requires the State Commission to introduce open access within one year of the appointed date the fifth proviso makes it mandatory for the State Commission to provide open access to all consumers who require supply of electricity where the maximum power to be made available at any time exceeds 1 MW.  The fifth proviso was introduced by Act 57 of 2003 with effect from 27th January 2004”.

“The first issue is if open access is made obligatory whether the distribution licensees will continue to have the responsibility of universal service obligations with regard to consumers whose requirements are in excess of 1 MW.  An analysis of the various provisions (particularly section 49 of the Act) shows that if certain consumers want to have the benefit of the option to buy power from competing sources, then it is logical that DISCOMS do not have an obligation to compulsorily supply power to such consumers.  If such consumers want power from the DISCOM then  the terms and conditions of the supply would be determined in terms of section 49 of DISCOM also”.

“There is no conflict between the aforesaid conclusion and the provisions of section 42(3) of the Act which provides that a person requiring supply of electricity has to give notice in respect thereof.  If the consumer intends to use the network of the DISCOMS, he has to give notice and upon such notice to DISCOM (it) is duty bound to provide non-discriminatory open access to its network.  Section 42(3) cannot be construed to mean that giving of a notice is a pre-condition for the implementation of open access”.

The directives issued by MoP shall have great impact on power sector particularly Electricity consumers, generators, traders and power market.  There are positive as well as negative sides which are to be looked into minutely.  The Commission will have a great responsibility to implement the suggestions of MoP by making suitable Regulation as well as to protect consumers against some negative points which are elaborated below.

POSITIVE POINTS:
  1. Consumers of 1 MW and above are deemed OA consumers and shall have choice of purchase of power from cheaper sources including Discom. 
  2. The tariff of such consumers shall not be regulated by Commission and the heavy burden of cross subsidies shall not be loaded to such consumers. 

Friday, August 5, 2011

Why Customer's Satisfaction & Preferences are important for Electricity Utilities?

The Forum of Regulators Report on Standardization of the Distribution Franchisee model (September 2010) mentions that the objectives of appointing a distribution franchisee, inter alia,
are:
i. To minimise Aggregate Distribution and Commercial losses
ii. To bring improvement in Metering, Billing and Revenue Collection
iii. To minimise Current Assets on account of arrears
iv. To enhance customer satisfaction level by improving quality of service

Placing focus on the fourth point, we find that while much information is shared in the Distribution Franchisee RFPs, they hardly provide any information on the current customer satisfaction levels nor the customer's perspective of the network infrastructure, current quality of services etc. This is a stark thing to miss considering all CERC, CEA, State ERCs and State Discom's mandate Improving Customer Satisfaction as one of the 4 objectives of a Power Distribution Franchisee. The reason probably for the miss is that the areas being offered for franchisee are any way loss making and hence customer dissatisfaction is well understood.

However, while all utilities, licensees and potential or current distribution franchisee operators try to improve quality of service; could efforts to understand the customer's perception and expectations from the utility help the utility make more quality decisions to improve the services and have a happy, paying customer?

The answer probably is a big "Yes". Measuring customer satisfaction - using a structured methodology that relates the customer responses with consumer demographics and key factors/attributes affecting business performance - is probably the only way of independently & periodically benchmarking effectiveness of utilities operating in same or different zones. No doubt a number of such mechanisms have evolved and established themselves in the western countries where multiple state / private companies operate in the same locality.

But how really could measuring customer satisfaction or proactively identifying customer preferences help? We believe, they could in the following key ways,

Sunday, July 10, 2011

Real gains for Utility and End-Consumers from Distribution Franchisee business

An obvious question with so much projected on Distribution Franchisee (DF) model is:
What real gains both the utility and end-consumers could expect coming out of the Distribution Franchisee model?
While Bhiwandi implementation of Distribution Franchisee has shown increased consumer satisfaction for improved service levels, but it is yet to be proved conclusively that the model has brought any significant monetary gains to the utility. The slow emergence of a potential impactful model (distribution franchisee) amidst opposition - from utility employees and end-consumers, could be attributed to missing INFORMATION and transparency. Opposition from utility employees is obvious as DF with its flavor of privatization is based upon driving cost efficiency by increasing productivity and hence reducing on numbers of utility employees. But opposition and fear from end-consumers is little less understood, when it doesn't matter that same power at same tariff (decided by State regulators & common to the state) comes from utility or DF. May be this fear from end-consumers has some roots in weaken regulation/enforcement or mis-information or perceived apprehensions.

In any case, going forward there are many questions, that needs clarification to smoothen resistance, but more importantly to engage all stakeholders well to co-create sustainable solutions. A few of importance are:
  1. With reduced AT&C losses from 50+% to order of 15% and reduced administrative & operations costs, could it be expected to see decreasing power tariffs (or atleast no changes for 5-10 years inspite of rise in power procurement costs) as realised by end-consumers? If and how does DF monetary gains could be shared with its end-consumers?
    • Since there is only one state level tariff plan prepared, consolidating audit reports from each circles/zones, the good and bad performances of different circles (including that of Franchisee's) get mixed to create one tariff plan. So in such case unless more decentralization penetrates in distribution, that DF circle end-consumers cannot expect their tariff plan alone to be improved. If however DF model scales all through out the state, then combined benefits could still bring common savings to all state end-consumers.

    • Above would also mean that even if one circle's management did a poor job of cutting its AT&C losses, there is no way of penalizing them independently. The entire state end-consumers get penalized equally. This is one serious missing incentive structure that has plagued utility's performance.

  2. How does exactly DF implementation improves profitability of the utility?
    • What are financial calculations that local utility has to consider to make a strong case for bringing in Distribution Franchisee over business-as-usual case? What profits (if any) can utility expect by leasing out its assets for 15 years to Distribution Franchisee?
    • How does the effective cost of distribution to local utility is accounted in setting benchmark input rates and its locking for next 15 years? We only hear the price realization terms like ABR (Average Billing Rate) and tariff setting term ARR (Aggregate Revenue Requirements) in RFP, but no comparison of these with actual cost of distribution.
    • Has post DF termination and appropriate depreciation of assets already being accounted in investment decision making?
    • Is utility prepared to take charge again post DF tenure or will it re-lease another DF term or there will be full privatization?
Post by: Rahul Bagdia @ pManifold

Wednesday, July 6, 2011

Upcoming Projects of Power Distribution Franchisee in Madhya Pradesh

A previous blog covered the market status report of ongoing and upcoming projects in Power Distribution Franchisee. This blog provides an updates and showcases recent activity of Power Distribution Franchisee in Madhya Pradesh (MP).

The table below provides the brief summary of Power Distribution Franchisee projects of 9 districts in MP.


 Distribution Franchisees RFP References:

  1. Narsinghpur
  2. Satna
  3. Sagar
  4. Datia
  5. Bhind
  6. Gwalior
  7. Shajapur
  8. Dewas
  9. Ujjain

Saturday, April 23, 2011

Limitations of existing baseline data shared for Power Distribution Franchisee bidding

The current approach to furnish baseline information for Distribution Franchisee (DF) RFP undertaken by the utility has following limitations:
  1. Very high level indicators (on distribution losses; collection efficiencies; customer mix and connected load distribution, arrear’s for each consumer class, brief count of network assets) are shared with no systematic causal analysis to allow bidders to diagnose network's status-quo for capital investment projection. This hampers calculated and informed bidding to happen.

  2. With highly fragmented databases and lack of integrated measurements & good practices on utility's side, the integrity of the top-level data provided is looked upon with doubt, thus making it highly risky investment for the bidders.

  3. In lack of measurements and system level analysis before bidding, the utilities themselves do not have right judgment about the required expenditure and potential revenue increase the area could give under able DF project time. The arising low confidence let them compromise on various aspects of good contract design and post monitoring and not able to get full benefits of the DF model.

Impact that could come from Utility Measurements, Analytics and Monitoring

There are ongoing lot of controversies about Power Distribution Franchisee (DF) applications and transparency of businesses running them. While some of them are definitely right and need to be intervened, but many of them are arising from missing information. Our earlier blog 'Lack of good baseline data & reporting leads to irrational Power Franchisee bidding' discussed the impact of this missing information on all stakeholders connected to Distribution Franchisee.

A perspective 'What's there in Distribution Power Franchisee?' was shared earlier. In line to that and at an abstraction level of a model, DF is about driving Measurements & Analytics, establishing baseline and monitoring performance to excel baseline and set a new one. The transition to a private ownership is one approach, which is believed to yield faster results. But it is not impossible to drive efficiency through state utilities by strict enforcement of driving interventions based on Measurements and Analytics. R-APDRP is one such attempt, but the gaps in handling the associated change management has led to increasing questions on real impact of the scheme - 'R-APDRP: Missing understanding on usability of technology by utility people'

Below is a visualization of positives that could come in the Indian power distribution sector through deeper acceptance and embedding of philosophy of measurements, analytics and monitoring.

Friday, April 22, 2011

Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) for Distribution Utility

Utility Performance Monitoring is one of major gaps in Indian distribution utility or DISCOMs. The major reason is missing measurements and analytics to drive decisions and implementations. Even the MIS that gets created (inspite of its questionable integrity) is not effectively used to control distribution system optimally. One abstraction is to look utility as a complex distributed network with multiple stakeholders/nodes (various end consumers, linked to DTCs, feeders and substations forming a network and one network interconnected with others). Each stakeholder has different metrics of performance and it is this mismatch of KPIs along various stakeholders, that make the network run non-optimally.

It is attempted here to give readers a detailed list of KPIs that could be applied to benchmark performance of a utility with other utilities or with itself across time. The list is not claimed to be complete, but have been arrived with good amalgamation from available literatures. The various broad categories of KPI's identified in utility distribution are:
  1. Operational Performance
  2. Operational Cost & Management
  3. Financial Performance
  4. Customer Service Quality
  5. Energy Efficiency & Demand Side Management (DSM)
  6. Workforce (Including Health & Safety)
  7. Sustainability

Lack of good baseline data & reporting leads to irrational Power Franchisee bidding


The reported success of Bhiwandi Power Franchisee model has attracted more private players and has increased competition for good of the sector (see our earlier blog on 'Many new corporates entering into emerging Power Distribution Franchisee race'). However the very basis of the Power Distribution Franchisee (DF) contract, the baseline data ('information') provided as part of the RFP (Request for Proposal) is not trusted by the bidders driving  irrationality in the bidding. 

Impact on Bidders:
  1. High business risk for the DF due to non-trust worthiness of the baseline data provided by the utility: Crompton Greaves Ltd. (CGL) backed from awarded Nagpur DF tender and in the process wasted 2 years. Company quoted that the base line data provided to them was not correct and its not viable for them to service at their quoted input rates.
  2. Repeated efforts by all bidders to gain confidence on baseline data: Since utility does not take responsibility of the data it provides in the RFP, it is left to the bidders to figure out this information and speculate their bid with little confidence on their business plan and projected returns.

Power Distribution Franchisee - Evolution from Rural to Urban and back to Rural


The Power Distribution Franchisee (DF) model is a precursor for privatization of distribution business in India. Under the model, the state retains ownership of the distribution asset and only leases O&M for defined contract period. On account of heavy capex already laid by the Government and its desire to keep its influence on this major portfolio, DF model will be the next generation model before the sector will start seeing full privatization.

The idea of DF first originated from Rural Electrification with the need of a low cost local agency to manage billing and collection at remote villages. Now that model remains no longer economically viable because of shortage of power directed to rural feeders. Then the shift of DF model application from Rural to Urban happened with piloting of new emerged Input Franchisee model for urban cities with heavy ATC losses. The selection of urban cities for DF model is driven by they having:

  1. steady demand loads
  2. relatively better collection efficiency, 
  3. less subsidized customers 
  4. good power supply
  5. political will and attention

Wednesday, April 20, 2011

Trends in Power Distribution Franchisee bidding RFPs - Qualifications and Bidding model

The Franchisee model in Power Distribution has picked up well with many RFPs post Bhiwandi pilot. Below is a comparison across different RFPs and states to enable a easy comparison around bidding qualification requirements and bidding structure. This should help bidders to form macro perspective of blocking their investment and efforts for new Distribution Franchisee bids. Earlier blog 'Market Status - Ongoing and coming projects in DF' discuss new prospective bids. MSEDCL (Maharashtra) has next potential DF sites in Malegaon, Ahmednagar, Beed, Parbhani and Hingoli.



Power Distribution Franchisee RFPs comparison (Source: pManifold)
(Click on the image to see the enlarged view)

Tuesday, April 19, 2011

ERP role in emerging Distribution utility reforms

Indian Power sector is in a rapid growth phase and in a phase of undergoing rapid change - change in a way they used to operate. A special emphasis is laid by the government on the electricity distribution industry to improve their operational and business efficiency. On an average the SEBs suffer from an ATC loss in the upwards of 30-35 % and in some areas even more. The R-APDRP programme has laid emphasis on the reform and implementation of IT systems (see our earlier blog on R-APDRP). ERP (Enterprise Resource Planning) is one of the most important enablers in providing an environment for integration of utility applications.

The typical characteristics of an electricity distribution business are:
 - Wide Geographic delivery areas
 - Infrastructure is distributed
 - Equipment installed and maintained for 30 years or more.
 - Uncertain business models
 - Evolving Deregulation

Monday, April 18, 2011

Workshop compilation from pManifold - Utility Monitoring and Power Distribution Franchisee: Enhancing SEB's Performance

pManifold as Knowledge Partner to IIES 2011 organized a workshop on 'Utility Monitoring & Distribution Power Franchise - Enhancing SEB's Performance'. The workshop was co-chaired with domain experts Mr. Murhari Kele, Supt. Engg. MSEDCL, Nagpur and Mr. Prabhakar Kukde, Ex-Direcor, Tata Power.

Friday, April 15, 2011

Components of AT&C losses - mystery behind the number

Ever wonder what it means by Aggregate Technical and Commercial (AT&C) losses in power sector? It is one number that affects all stakeholders of power chain directly including the end-consumers. If AT&C losses are higher, then your distribution utility or DISCOM would go ahead making a case to its state Electric Regulatory Commission (ERC) during its Aggregate Revenue Requirement (ARR) filing for new and increased tariff orders. It works with DISCOM making a case that it has procured power of 'X' amount, but have received only X-- amount on account of AT&C losses and now with increased demand and rising supply prices and make up its arrears, it needs to increase tariff for next year.

R-APDRP: Missing understanding on usability of technology by utility people

The Restructured Accelerated Power Distribution Reforms Program (R-APDRP) of the Government of India is an ambitious program aimed at achieving significant loss reduction of the distribution utilities in the public sector. The Rs. 30K cr. deployment by 2012 makes it probably one of world's biggest scale IT deployment in utilities. The program has two parts. The Part-A, aims at using IT to create base line data and Part-B aims at strengthening the electrical network for reducing losses and improving the level of service delivery and quality of power to customers.

Tuesday, April 12, 2011

Performance Analysis of Distribution Franchisee - Bhiwandi Case study by Torrent Power Limited

Bhiwandi, Maharashtra saw the first successful pilot of Power Distribution Franchisee (DF), with Torrent Power Ltd. (TPL) as selected Franchisee and MSEDCL the original licensee. The model adopted was Input based franchisee - with TPL agreeing to purchase power from MSEDCL at the input point to Bhiwandi circle at year-wise fixed input energy rate (Rs./kWh) for a contract period of 10 years and executing distribution responsibilities including metering, billing, revenue collection, repair, maintenance, O&M cost of network, consumer service, capital expenditure, allocating new connections etc. With operations commenced from 26th Jan 2007, TPL has completed a successful milestone of 3 years of its operations with ATC loss reduction from 58% to now 18.5%.

Thursday, April 7, 2011

Many new corporates entering into emerging Power Distribution Franchisee race

Power Distribution Franchisee has attracted various big corporate houses (see earlier blog). A distribution below of major players bidding in the market shows that most companies has come from services sector of Infrastructure and Power businesses. Those in Infrastructure like GMR, SMS, Ashoka Buildcon, A2Z & Kalpataru has earlier already diversified into Power sector primarily into Generation (balance of plant and EPC), distribution (substation EPC) and transmission (EPC). A more recent trend of these Infra companies further getting into generating and trading power (thermal, renewables, waste) is noteworthy. Now if absorbed into Distribution Franchisee, their portfolio will be pretty much covering all of power sector and building scope of economy.

Wednesday, April 6, 2011

Market status: Ongoing and coming projects in Power Distribution Franchisee

Inspired by the success of the Power Distribution Franchisee model of electricity at Bhiwandi, Maharashtra, many other states have started piloting the model. MSEDCL is probably the most active utility with piloting Power Distribution Franchisee model - Bhiwandi, Nagpur, Jalgaon and recently Shil, Mumbra & Kalwa with many others in pipeline in coming short time.