Showing posts with label consumer. Show all posts
Showing posts with label consumer. Show all posts

Wednesday, November 13, 2013

Interview with Col. Gowardhan - HR Director, OCW on the key challenges and future plans for 24 x 7 water supply project at Nagpur

The interview showcases the key challenges and future plans of the 24x7 water supply operator for the city of Nagpur, as told to Mohammad.Sufiyan@pManifold.com


Nagpur 24x7 water supply project is the first urban water supply project in India. Could you, at the outset, help us understand the current status of the Project?
Nagpur comes along as the first big urban water supply project on Public-Private-Partnership (PPP) model. In this Project, Orange City Water Pvt. Ltd. (OCW) is to upgrade city water distribution network through rehabilitation of the existing network and laying new network to achieve 24x7 uninterrupted water supply to city of Nagpur.The work is in progress under JnNRUM scheme. The plan agreed and approved for 5 years and in last 18 months OCW has been able to lay about 250 km of pipe line and done more than 26000 new service connections. One zone is already operating on 24x7 basis and few areas will be shortly added to 24x7 list as work in 3 areas is nearing completion.  Further to that, OCW is currently working in almost 30% of the city to improve the water mains network.

Tuesday, June 18, 2013

Top 15 - Field analysis of Customer Indexing for a Utility Company

GIS based consumer indexing is one of the effective tool to improve the complex network of consumers for the utility company. The complexity of network and minimal baseline data available, the utility needs to take substantial efforts on field to create a strong database of the consumer.

While working with a major water utility in India, some of our observations are listed below. These observations could help in creating a strong database of consumer.

Problems & Resulting Issues:

A) Systemic Problems (arising due to problem in process/system)

  • Background and purpose not clearly defined which is essential for correct inputs and improve the quality of data. 
  • Lack of strong processes and system base implementation for customer indexing
  • Recruitment of low quality people for on-field surveys which leads to lack of presentations skills, confidence, convincing capabilities, etc.
  • No processes for submission of on-field data which results in faulty batching of data and missing of survey forms
  • No regular updates of data (Monthly or Quarterly)
  • Lack of effort estimation and resource allocation which results in exceeding deadlines and duplication of efforts

B) Data Collection Problem (Due to Presentation / Understanding / Customer Support)

  • Wrong plot markings of property polygons in GIS base maps
  • Incomplete information filled by surveyor to achieve the daily target
  • Missed out consumers and properties by surveyors
  • No validation of Consumer Indexing process compliance by surveyors who are doing mistakes on field
  • No continuous tracking of surveyor records and inputs
  • Management of surveyors becomes difficult due to high attrition rate on-field
  • Difficulty in categorizing registered, unregistered and no-connection Consumers 
  • Lower level supervisors tackling the issues arising out of political influence may create unwanted barriers

Recommendations:

- Create a strong stakeholder (internal & external) agreement on what is required output of the consumer indexing survey
- One of the most effective ways to ensure high quality of data collected is to emphasize more on re-validation of the data by a field team
- Preliminary survey by taking GIS base map also helps to minimize GIS related issues on-field.
- On-field continuous training and quality monitoring of surveyors which will help minimise mistakes at ground level
- Appropriate costing and effort estimation is required for timely delivery of data
- Frequent updates of data is important which will help resolve to bring consistency in data

Prologue:

A systematic execution of customer indexing creates a whole new intelligence about the local variables. At the same time it can suggest strategic interventions which could be used for creating a positive cash flow for the utility.

Wednesday, October 31, 2012

Contingent Valuation Methodology - a means to the capture and analyze willingness to pay

If people merely ‘want’ something, it may not be backed with a willingness to pay for that service. Hence one needs to ascertain people’s maximum willingness to pay for service options under consideration. Willingness-To-Pay (WTP) is the maximum amount an individual is ready to pay for a particular goods/service. Consumer surveys are carried out to estimate the WTP for goods or service under consideration.

The WTP can be estimated using three different ways:
  1. By observing prices that people pay for similar goods in various other markets
  2. By observing individual expenditures on money, time and labor, etc. to obtain goods, OR to avoid their loss. This method might involve an assessment of coping strategies and involve observations, focus group discussions and even house-hold surveys.
  3. By directly asking people what they are willing to pay for goods and services in the future
The first two approaches are based on observations of behavior and are called Revealed Preference Techniques. The third technique is based upon Stated Preferences and includes Contingent Valuation Method.

Contingent Valuation Methodology (CVM) creates a hypothetical market scenario and tries to obtain the value for particular goods, contingent to the scenario. The economic concept that the CV Surveys are trying to capture is the maximum amount that the individual would be willing to pay for certain goods/services.

The most important part of the CV Survey is to simulate a realistic contingent valuation scenario, which has accurately priced options that reflect the levels of prices the goods/service provider will have to charge.

The advantages and disadvantages of the CVM are presented below:

CONTINGENT VALUATION METHOD

Advantages
Disadvantages
1
CVM captures a fuller range of benefits of service improvements by investigating people’s maximum willingness to pay for different levels of service that are currently not available
The cost of CVM analysis for a smaller project in terms of time and money are significant. However, incremental costs are relatively modest
2
Consumers can bid on a range of different service options, thereby defining project designs and technology choices
The results of CVM are often not transferable between locations. This creates a special focus requirement on sample planning
3
The CVM generates information on household ability and willingness to pay for on-going services, thereby guiding tariff and cost-recovery policy
Sample size needs to be substantial to avoid problems involved with aggregation of responses
4
If stated clearly, the results of CVM Survey are conceptually easy for non-specialists
Individual biases can cause misleading results

The CVM has proven to be the most popular of available methods for monetary valuation of environment.[1]

The application of Willingness-to-Pay Survey for a utility roll-out is depicted in the following figure. 

How Willingness-to-Pay Study fits into the operational roll-out for utilities?
The chart shows how the study integrates with the other functions of the utility and interacts with them to create an eco-system based on optimum approximations.

Biases
When a respondent does not answer a survey question truthfully, it is said to introduce a bias into the survey that undermines the validity of the survey. Therefore, the basic design consideration of the CV Survey is to avoid the many biases that might occur.

The different types of biases and the ways to avoid the biases in your CVM study are shown in the table below. These biases also need to be controlled during the interview conducted for the CVM Study.

Main CVM Biases and Errors
Bias
Characteristic
How to avoid
Low Strategic Bid
Respondent lowers their bid assuming that the state, or others, will pay more
Emphasize on policy of state that if the community is not willing to pay sufficiently, the project might not take off
High Strategic Bid
Respondent raises their bid above the real WTP to ensure that the project goes ahead
Make it clear that there will be no subsidies, this is the real amount. Choose correct bidding model
Hypothetical Bias
Respondent does not understand or believe in the options
Explain options clearly.
Poor Sampling
Non-random sample selected which might result in poor quality of data collected.
Ensure accurate mapping of survey area and an appropriate random sampling methodology
Starting Point Bias
Starting price for bidding games influences the final WTP
Vary the starting prices within the sampling frame
Interview and Compliance Bias
Enumerator influenced biases
Analyze responses by enumerator and discard biased responses
Payment Method Bias
Payment method does somehow affect the responses
This might be a realistic bias revealing preferences to certain payment method. This can be safely ignored.

Best practices for Designing WTP Survey
1.     ·  Survey Design should involve easily understood and pre-tested language, taking feedback from all focus group ·   Data Collection should be planned with appropriate attention to sample size, collection methods, sample representation of general population, and randomized selection ·     Correct statistical tests need to be applied for accurate interpretation of the results ·  Regression results for CVM bids should be conducted for validating the data ·  Question Design and interview process should be developed to reduce the bias introduced in the survey

For a case study on WTP for Water, visit our blog here.


[1] “The Contingent Valuation Method: Retrospect and Prospect” (2008), Clive L. Spash



Sunday, October 14, 2012

Case Study: Willingness To Pay for Water

There has been an uncertainty around the success of the PPP models in the Indian Utility Market. While some of the fears are well placed, I think that one of the best ways to counter the apprehensions over the revenue projections of the operators, is the Willingness-to-Pay (WTP) analysis of the consumers in question.

The WTP analysis provides a localized and a  stratified consumer response across the socio-economic categories, if well planned and executed. The figure below shows a typical boxplot drawn for a consumer analysis done for one of our clients.
Box-Plot for a typical WTP Study

The client - a private PPP Water Utility operator - had taken over the water supply project of a town with approx 2 lacs consumers. The operator had approached a leading institution for financing the over INR 1000 Cr.

The institutional investor had his apprehensions about the revenue projections and had approached us to do the top-line validation through a WTP Survey and Analysis.

The existing water supply condition of the city was very poor and residents were facing utmost difficulties in meeting their requirements through the ULB supplied water.

We designed the WTP Study using the Contingent Valuation Methodology (CVM) and developed the  framework to execute the study. Key findings, which can be generally seen across other Water consumers, are shown in the adjoining figure.
Key Findings of the WTP Study

The findings helped the operator impress the necessity of the improved quality of water supply and prove that the people, if provided with better services, are willing to bear the cost for the service improvement as well.

The WTP Study did manage to help the operator get to the financial closure.

As we discussed the findings and success story of the WTP Study, we are now engaging with clients not just from the Utility Operators, but even from other service sector enterprises who want to validate their top-line projections before launching new or improved services.