Friday, July 22, 2011

Attracting and retaining the top-third graduates for careers in teaching

I interact with a number of engineering and management education institutions on a regular basis. One thing I notice always is the faculty at these institutions. Where we mostly talk about improving the "teaching", really no one talks about hiring the best teachers for various reasons.

The research by McKinsey on the "Talent Gap: Attracting and retaining the top-third graduates for careers in teaching" identifies this as an opportunity to improve the academic delivery and also as a measure that has strong correlation to the economic performance of the country. The report makes an interesting remark stating that "Top performing nations recruit 100% of their new teachers from the top third. In the U.S., its 23% and 14% in high poverty schools". The report also talks about the many other factors on which graduates decide their occupation other than monetary considerations.

Of course I didn't come across a similar opportunity study done for India, but I guess it is a fair opportunity for tier 2/3 institutions in India as well to attempt and create an ecosystem which is amicable for hiring teachers from top third of the graduates.

Aren't there ways and means to leverage this in the Indian context?

Wednesday, July 20, 2011

Distribution Franchisee Attractiveness - Comparison for Madhya Pradesh's 9 districts

Madhya Pradesh (MP) has come out with 9 districts tenders for Power Distribution Franchisee business (see our earlier blog 'Upcoming Projects of Power Distribution Franchisee in Madhya Pradesh for more details on districts and corresponding RFPs'.

One bigger question that all prospective bidders are now evaluating is 'Which areas to go for bidding?'.

MP 9 districts benchmarking on 'Distribution Franchisee Attractiveness'
(Source - pManifold Analysis from secondary research and RFP data)

Sunday, July 17, 2011

Are emerging cities listening to the call of Europe?

Yesterday, I attended a Science and Technology Awareness Raising and Information Campaign in India organized at Nagpur. They are visiting almost 22 cities in India including tier 2/3 cities for promoting European Union's (EU) research focus and support system.

Lot of interesting things were shared including a memory stick containing detailed information on the research funding and opportunities provided by member states especially for Indians.

Two important things that stood out:

  1. There are funding opportunities available for individual researchers and SMEs under the European Union's 7th Research Framework Program. Especially in Information and Communication Technologies (ICT), the research investment that has been made has been the maximum amounting to over 9 billion euros. The special support for funding research projects for SMEs is also an interesting endeavor to encourage application oriented research.
  2. There is a proper support system in the form of European Business and Technology Center (EBTC), which promotes innovative technologies and converts research into commercial ventures. Although their focus is on cleantech, however a lot of ICT get's involved here too. EBTC can help connect innovative, local businesses with European counterparts for collaborative programs.

The EU delegation campaign was an informative one, at Hotel Pride, Wardha road, Nagpur, with a delicious lunch that followed. However, only 20 odd people comprising of entrepreneurs, academicians and researchers attended the conference. The EU is opening up to India, but are we from emerging cities listening to the call?

http://growit.in/expert-talk/opportunities/271-are-emerging-cities-listening-to-the-call-of-europe.html>

Sunday, July 10, 2011

Real gains for Utility and End-Consumers from Distribution Franchisee business

An obvious question with so much projected on Distribution Franchisee (DF) model is:
What real gains both the utility and end-consumers could expect coming out of the Distribution Franchisee model?
While Bhiwandi implementation of Distribution Franchisee has shown increased consumer satisfaction for improved service levels, but it is yet to be proved conclusively that the model has brought any significant monetary gains to the utility. The slow emergence of a potential impactful model (distribution franchisee) amidst opposition - from utility employees and end-consumers, could be attributed to missing INFORMATION and transparency. Opposition from utility employees is obvious as DF with its flavor of privatization is based upon driving cost efficiency by increasing productivity and hence reducing on numbers of utility employees. But opposition and fear from end-consumers is little less understood, when it doesn't matter that same power at same tariff (decided by State regulators & common to the state) comes from utility or DF. May be this fear from end-consumers has some roots in weaken regulation/enforcement or mis-information or perceived apprehensions.

In any case, going forward there are many questions, that needs clarification to smoothen resistance, but more importantly to engage all stakeholders well to co-create sustainable solutions. A few of importance are:
  1. With reduced AT&C losses from 50+% to order of 15% and reduced administrative & operations costs, could it be expected to see decreasing power tariffs (or atleast no changes for 5-10 years inspite of rise in power procurement costs) as realised by end-consumers? If and how does DF monetary gains could be shared with its end-consumers?
    • Since there is only one state level tariff plan prepared, consolidating audit reports from each circles/zones, the good and bad performances of different circles (including that of Franchisee's) get mixed to create one tariff plan. So in such case unless more decentralization penetrates in distribution, that DF circle end-consumers cannot expect their tariff plan alone to be improved. If however DF model scales all through out the state, then combined benefits could still bring common savings to all state end-consumers.

    • Above would also mean that even if one circle's management did a poor job of cutting its AT&C losses, there is no way of penalizing them independently. The entire state end-consumers get penalized equally. This is one serious missing incentive structure that has plagued utility's performance.

  2. How does exactly DF implementation improves profitability of the utility?
    • What are financial calculations that local utility has to consider to make a strong case for bringing in Distribution Franchisee over business-as-usual case? What profits (if any) can utility expect by leasing out its assets for 15 years to Distribution Franchisee?
    • How does the effective cost of distribution to local utility is accounted in setting benchmark input rates and its locking for next 15 years? We only hear the price realization terms like ABR (Average Billing Rate) and tariff setting term ARR (Aggregate Revenue Requirements) in RFP, but no comparison of these with actual cost of distribution.
    • Has post DF termination and appropriate depreciation of assets already being accounted in investment decision making?
    • Is utility prepared to take charge again post DF tenure or will it re-lease another DF term or there will be full privatization?
Post by: Rahul Bagdia @ pManifold

Wednesday, July 6, 2011

Upcoming Projects of Power Distribution Franchisee in Madhya Pradesh

A previous blog covered the market status report of ongoing and upcoming projects in Power Distribution Franchisee. This blog provides an updates and showcases recent activity of Power Distribution Franchisee in Madhya Pradesh (MP).

The table below provides the brief summary of Power Distribution Franchisee projects of 9 districts in MP.


 Distribution Franchisees RFP References:

  1. Narsinghpur
  2. Satna
  3. Sagar
  4. Datia
  5. Bhind
  6. Gwalior
  7. Shajapur
  8. Dewas
  9. Ujjain

Saturday, April 23, 2011

Limitations of existing baseline data shared for Power Distribution Franchisee bidding

The current approach to furnish baseline information for Distribution Franchisee (DF) RFP undertaken by the utility has following limitations:
  1. Very high level indicators (on distribution losses; collection efficiencies; customer mix and connected load distribution, arrear’s for each consumer class, brief count of network assets) are shared with no systematic causal analysis to allow bidders to diagnose network's status-quo for capital investment projection. This hampers calculated and informed bidding to happen.

  2. With highly fragmented databases and lack of integrated measurements & good practices on utility's side, the integrity of the top-level data provided is looked upon with doubt, thus making it highly risky investment for the bidders.

  3. In lack of measurements and system level analysis before bidding, the utilities themselves do not have right judgment about the required expenditure and potential revenue increase the area could give under able DF project time. The arising low confidence let them compromise on various aspects of good contract design and post monitoring and not able to get full benefits of the DF model.

Impact that could come from Utility Measurements, Analytics and Monitoring

There are ongoing lot of controversies about Power Distribution Franchisee (DF) applications and transparency of businesses running them. While some of them are definitely right and need to be intervened, but many of them are arising from missing information. Our earlier blog 'Lack of good baseline data & reporting leads to irrational Power Franchisee bidding' discussed the impact of this missing information on all stakeholders connected to Distribution Franchisee.

A perspective 'What's there in Distribution Power Franchisee?' was shared earlier. In line to that and at an abstraction level of a model, DF is about driving Measurements & Analytics, establishing baseline and monitoring performance to excel baseline and set a new one. The transition to a private ownership is one approach, which is believed to yield faster results. But it is not impossible to drive efficiency through state utilities by strict enforcement of driving interventions based on Measurements and Analytics. R-APDRP is one such attempt, but the gaps in handling the associated change management has led to increasing questions on real impact of the scheme - 'R-APDRP: Missing understanding on usability of technology by utility people'

Below is a visualization of positives that could come in the Indian power distribution sector through deeper acceptance and embedding of philosophy of measurements, analytics and monitoring.

Friday, April 22, 2011

Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) for Distribution Utility

Utility Performance Monitoring is one of major gaps in Indian distribution utility or DISCOMs. The major reason is missing measurements and analytics to drive decisions and implementations. Even the MIS that gets created (inspite of its questionable integrity) is not effectively used to control distribution system optimally. One abstraction is to look utility as a complex distributed network with multiple stakeholders/nodes (various end consumers, linked to DTCs, feeders and substations forming a network and one network interconnected with others). Each stakeholder has different metrics of performance and it is this mismatch of KPIs along various stakeholders, that make the network run non-optimally.

It is attempted here to give readers a detailed list of KPIs that could be applied to benchmark performance of a utility with other utilities or with itself across time. The list is not claimed to be complete, but have been arrived with good amalgamation from available literatures. The various broad categories of KPI's identified in utility distribution are:
  1. Operational Performance
  2. Operational Cost & Management
  3. Financial Performance
  4. Customer Service Quality
  5. Energy Efficiency & Demand Side Management (DSM)
  6. Workforce (Including Health & Safety)
  7. Sustainability

Lack of good baseline data & reporting leads to irrational Power Franchisee bidding


The reported success of Bhiwandi Power Franchisee model has attracted more private players and has increased competition for good of the sector (see our earlier blog on 'Many new corporates entering into emerging Power Distribution Franchisee race'). However the very basis of the Power Distribution Franchisee (DF) contract, the baseline data ('information') provided as part of the RFP (Request for Proposal) is not trusted by the bidders driving  irrationality in the bidding. 

Impact on Bidders:
  1. High business risk for the DF due to non-trust worthiness of the baseline data provided by the utility: Crompton Greaves Ltd. (CGL) backed from awarded Nagpur DF tender and in the process wasted 2 years. Company quoted that the base line data provided to them was not correct and its not viable for them to service at their quoted input rates.
  2. Repeated efforts by all bidders to gain confidence on baseline data: Since utility does not take responsibility of the data it provides in the RFP, it is left to the bidders to figure out this information and speculate their bid with little confidence on their business plan and projected returns.

Power Distribution Franchisee - Evolution from Rural to Urban and back to Rural


The Power Distribution Franchisee (DF) model is a precursor for privatization of distribution business in India. Under the model, the state retains ownership of the distribution asset and only leases O&M for defined contract period. On account of heavy capex already laid by the Government and its desire to keep its influence on this major portfolio, DF model will be the next generation model before the sector will start seeing full privatization.

The idea of DF first originated from Rural Electrification with the need of a low cost local agency to manage billing and collection at remote villages. Now that model remains no longer economically viable because of shortage of power directed to rural feeders. Then the shift of DF model application from Rural to Urban happened with piloting of new emerged Input Franchisee model for urban cities with heavy ATC losses. The selection of urban cities for DF model is driven by they having:

  1. steady demand loads
  2. relatively better collection efficiency, 
  3. less subsidized customers 
  4. good power supply
  5. political will and attention